The United States has denied accusations of leveraging Starlink’s satellite internet to exert political pressure, yet Europe is already preparing contingency plans for Ukraine. Starlink has been crucial for Ukraine’s defense against Russia, providing critical communication and coordination on the front lines. However, recent reports suggest the US might restrict access unless Ukraine grants permission to exploit its rare earth resources, sparking a complex geopolitical power struggle.
Starlink’s Pivotal Role in Ukraine’s Defense
Since the war’s outset, SpaceX’s Starlink, spearheaded by Elon Musk, has been indispensable for Ukraine, ensuring reliable internet even in areas where traditional networks are compromised. The US government initially supported the service financially after Musk highlighted its unsustainable cost—around $80 million per year for 25,000 terminals. Allies, including Poland, also contributed to funding.
However, tensions arose when Musk restricted Starlink access in Russian-occupied areas. Additionally, reports claimed Musk privately spoke with Vladimir Putin about the conflict, leading to suspicions that the US might use Starlink as a bargaining chip. While Musk and former President Trump have denied such intentions, concerns persist.
Europe’s Strategic Response: Eutelsat and OneWeb
In response to potential disruptions, Europe is positioning itself with alternative solutions. The EU is in talks with Eutelsat, which operates the OneWeb satellite network. Although OneWeb’s capacity doesn’t match Starlink’s, it offers global coverage with satellites positioned at 1,200 kilometers—significantly higher than Starlink’s 400 kilometers. Eutelsat CEO Eva Berneke stated that their network could maintain secure satellite communication even if Starlink becomes unavailable.
Eutelsat’s stock has surged amid speculation of a Starlink shutdown, reflecting growing confidence in Europe’s contingency plans. Meanwhile, the EU is developing its own IRIS² satellite infrastructure to ensure secure communication, expected to be fully operational by 2026.
Long-Term Solutions and Challenges
Beyond OneWeb, Europe is exploring additional options, including Luxembourg’s SES O3b mPower system. However, with only six active satellites, it still lacks the scale of Starlink. The EU is also evaluating whether Ukraine could access the GOVSATCOM network for secure military communications.
While Europe intensifies its satellite strategy, the most immediate challenge for Ukraine may be the loss of US intelligence support. Reports indicate that Washington has reduced the flow of real-time intelligence data to Kyiv, potentially undermining Ukraine’s ability to track enemy movements. Military experts warn that without satellite connectivity and intelligence, Russia’s strategic advantage could grow significantly.
Despite these challenges, Ukraine’s Defense Minister Rustem Umjerow remains optimistic, asserting that the country has never been solely reliant on Starlink. As Europe works to strengthen its technological infrastructure, the geopolitical landscape around satellite internet continues to evolve.
Read More on Internet Today.
